Description:

I was quite surprised to come across a recording of La Traviata featuring Josephine Barstow. The darker color and weightier quality of her voice are not characteristics typically associated with Violetta, yet she conveys the role’s pathos with extraordinary depth while navigating “Sempre libera” with impressive skill. The English National Opera wisely cast the supporting roles with larger voices to complement Barstow’s distinctive timbre.

John Brecknock, though not possessing an overtly Italianate sound, successfully alternates between sweet lyricism and dramatic intensity over the course of the performance. Neil Howlett delivers a strong and convincing Germont, while Sarah Walker brings charm and vibrancy to the often-overlooked role of Flora.

The sound is decent but slightly distant. The English text is not always clear, particularly from Barstow.

OD 10637-2